A bug was reported in the context in issue #3631. The root cause of the
bug was that certain neighbor boxes were zeroed after the "inside the
bounding box or not" check, simply because the bounding box computation
function was wrong.
A few debugging infos where enhanced and moved in other parts of the
code. A check to avoid steps=0 was added, but is unrelated to this
issue and I did not verified it was an actual bug in practice.
By grepping the continuous integration errors log a number of GEORADIUS
tests failures were detected.
Fortunately when a GEORADIUS failure happens, the test suite logs enough
information in order to reproduce the problem: the PRNG seed,
coordinates and radius of the query.
By reproducing the issues, three different bugs were discovered and
fixed in this commit. This commit also improves the already good
reporting of the fuzzer and adds the failure vectors as regression
tests.
The issues found:
1. We need larger squares around the poles in order to cover the area
requested by the user. There were already checks in order to use a
smaller step (larger squares) but the limit set (+/- 67 degrees) is not
enough in certain edge cases, so 66 is used now.
2. Even near the equator, when the search area center is very near the
edge of the square, the north, south, west or ovest square may not be
able to fully cover the specified radius. Now a test is performed at the
edge of the initial guessed search area, and larger squares are used in
case the test fails.
3. Because of rounding errors between Redis and Tcl, sometimes the test
signaled false positives. This is now addressed.
Whenever possible the original code was improved a bit in other ways. A
debugging example stanza was added in order to make the next debugging
session simpler when the next bug is found.
I'm the author of this line but I can't see a good reason for it to
don't be a typo, a step of 26 should be valid with 52 bits per
coordinate, moreover the line was:
if (step > 26) step = 25;
So a step of 26 was actually already used, except when one of 27 was
computed (which is invalid) only then it was trimmed to 25 instead of
26.
All tests passing after the change.
The GIS standard and all the major DBs implementing GIS related
functions take coordinates as x,y that is longitude,latitude.
It was a bad start for Redis to do things differently, so even if this
means that existing users of the Geo module will be required to change
their code, Redis now conforms to the standard.
Usually Redis is very backward compatible, but this is not an exception
to this rule, since this is the first Geo implementation entering the
official Redis source code. It is not wise to try to be backward
compatible with code forks... :-)
Close#2637.
The returned step was in some case not enough towards normal
coordinates (for example when our search position was was already near the
margin of the central area, and we had to match, using the east or west
neighbor, a very far point). Example:
geoadd points 67.575457940146066 -62.001317572780565 far
geoadd points 66.685439060295664 -58.925040587282297 center
georadius points 66.685439060295664 -58.925040587282297 200 km
In the above case the code failed to find a match (happens at smaller
latitudes too) even if far and center are at less than 200km.
Another fix introduced by this commit is a progressively larger area
towards the poles, since meridians are a lot less far away, so we need
to compensate for this.
The current implementation works comparably to the Tcl brute-force
stress tester implemented in the fuzzy test in the geo.tcl unit for
latitudes between -70 and 70, and is pretty accurate over +/-80 too,
with sporadic false negatives.
A more mathematically clean implementation is possible by computing the
meridian distance at the specified latitude and computing the step
according to it.
Current todo:
- replace functions in zset.{c,h} with a new unified Redis
zset access API.
Once we get the zset interface fixed, we can squash
relevant commits in this branch and have one nice commit
to merge into unstable.
This commit adds:
- Geo commands
- Tests; runnable with: ./runtest --single unit/geo
- Geo helpers in deps/geohash-int/
- src/geo.{c,h} and src/geojson.{c,h} implementing geo commands
- Updated build configurations to get everything working
- TEMPORARY: src/zset.{c,h} implementing zset score and zset
range reading without writing to client output buffers.
- Modified linkage of one t_zset.c function for use in zset.c
Conflicts:
src/Makefile
src/redis.c
