399 lines
14 KiB
Rust
Raw Normal View History

[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
// Copyright 2019 Parity Technologies (UK) Ltd.
//
// Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a
// copy of this software and associated documentation files (the "Software"),
// to deal in the Software without restriction, including without limitation
// the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense,
// and/or sell copies of the Software, and to permit persons to whom the
// Software is furnished to do so, subject to the following conditions:
//
// The above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in
// all copies or substantial portions of the Software.
//
// THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS", WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS
// OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY,
// FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE
// AUTHORS OR COPYRIGHT HOLDERS BE LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM, DAMAGES OR OTHER
// LIABILITY, WHETHER IN AN ACTION OF CONTRACT, TORT OR OTHERWISE, ARISING
// FROM, OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH THE SOFTWARE OR THE USE OR OTHER
// DEALINGS IN THE SOFTWARE.
use bytes::{BytesMut, Buf};
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
use crate::protocol::{Protocol, MessageReader, Message, Version, ProtocolError};
use futures::{prelude::*, Async, try_ready};
use log::debug;
use tokio_io::{AsyncRead, AsyncWrite};
use std::{mem, io, fmt, error::Error};
/// An I/O stream that has settled on an (application-layer) protocol to use.
///
/// A `Negotiated` represents an I/O stream that has _settled_ on a protocol
/// to use. In particular, it is not implied that all of the protocol negotiation
/// frames have yet been sent and / or received, just that the selected protocol
/// is fully determined. This is to allow the last protocol negotiation frames
/// sent by a peer to be combined in a single write, possibly piggy-backing
/// data from the negotiated protocol on top.
///
/// Reading from a `Negotiated` I/O stream that still has pending negotiation
/// protocol data to send implicitly triggers flushing of all yet unsent data.
#[derive(Debug)]
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
pub struct Negotiated<TInner> {
state: State<TInner>
}
/// A `Future` that waits on the completion of protocol negotiation.
#[derive(Debug)]
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
pub struct NegotiatedComplete<TInner> {
inner: Option<Negotiated<TInner>>
}
impl<TInner: AsyncRead + AsyncWrite> Future for NegotiatedComplete<TInner> {
type Item = Negotiated<TInner>;
type Error = NegotiationError;
fn poll(&mut self) -> Poll<Self::Item, Self::Error> {
let mut io = self.inner.take().expect("NegotiatedFuture called after completion.");
if io.poll()?.is_not_ready() {
self.inner = Some(io);
return Ok(Async::NotReady)
}
return Ok(Async::Ready(io))
}
}
impl<TInner> Negotiated<TInner> {
/// Creates a `Negotiated` in state [`State::Complete`], possibly
/// with `remaining` data to be sent.
pub(crate) fn completed(io: TInner, remaining: BytesMut) -> Self {
Negotiated { state: State::Completed { io, remaining } }
}
/// Creates a `Negotiated` in state [`State::Expecting`] that is still
/// expecting confirmation of the given `protocol`.
pub(crate) fn expecting(io: MessageReader<TInner>, protocol: Protocol, version: Version) -> Self {
Negotiated { state: State::Expecting { io, protocol, version } }
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
}
/// Polls the `Negotiated` for completion.
fn poll(&mut self) -> Poll<(), NegotiationError>
where
TInner: AsyncRead + AsyncWrite
{
// Flush any pending negotiation data.
match self.poll_flush() {
Ok(Async::Ready(())) => {},
Ok(Async::NotReady) => return Ok(Async::NotReady),
Err(e) => {
// If the remote closed the stream, it is important to still
// continue reading the data that was sent, if any.
if e.kind() != io::ErrorKind::WriteZero {
return Err(e.into())
}
}
}
if let State::Completed { remaining, .. } = &mut self.state {
let _ = remaining.split_to(remaining.len()); // Drop remaining data flushed above.
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
return Ok(Async::Ready(()))
}
// Read outstanding protocol negotiation messages.
loop {
match mem::replace(&mut self.state, State::Invalid) {
State::Expecting { mut io, protocol, version } => {
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
let msg = match io.poll() {
Ok(Async::Ready(Some(msg))) => msg,
Ok(Async::NotReady) => {
self.state = State::Expecting { io, protocol, version };
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
return Ok(Async::NotReady)
}
Ok(Async::Ready(None)) => {
self.state = State::Expecting { io, protocol, version };
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
return Err(ProtocolError::IoError(
io::ErrorKind::UnexpectedEof.into()).into())
}
Err(err) => {
self.state = State::Expecting { io, protocol, version };
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
return Err(err.into())
}
};
if let Message::Header(v) = &msg {
if v == &version {
self.state = State::Expecting { io, protocol, version };
continue
}
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
}
if let Message::Protocol(p) = &msg {
if p.as_ref() == protocol.as_ref() {
debug!("Negotiated: Received confirmation for protocol: {}", p);
let (io, remaining) = io.into_inner();
self.state = State::Completed { io, remaining };
return Ok(Async::Ready(()))
}
}
return Err(NegotiationError::Failed)
}
_ => panic!("Negotiated: Invalid state")
}
}
}
/// Returns a `NegotiatedComplete` future that waits for protocol
/// negotiation to complete.
pub fn complete(self) -> NegotiatedComplete<TInner> {
NegotiatedComplete { inner: Some(self) }
}
}
/// The states of a `Negotiated` I/O stream.
#[derive(Debug)]
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
enum State<R> {
/// In this state, a `Negotiated` is still expecting to
/// receive confirmation of the protocol it as settled on.
Expecting {
/// The underlying I/O stream.
io: MessageReader<R>,
/// The expected protocol (i.e. name and version).
protocol: Protocol,
/// The expected multistream-select protocol version.
version: Version
},
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
/// In this state, a protocol has been agreed upon and may
/// only be pending the sending of the final acknowledgement,
/// which is prepended to / combined with the next write for
/// efficiency.
Completed { io: R, remaining: BytesMut },
/// Temporary state while moving the `io` resource from
/// `Expecting` to `Completed`.
Invalid,
}
impl<R> io::Read for Negotiated<R>
where
R: AsyncRead + AsyncWrite
{
fn read(&mut self, buf: &mut [u8]) -> io::Result<usize> {
loop {
if let State::Completed { io, remaining } = &mut self.state {
// If protocol negotiation is complete and there is no
// remaining data to be flushed, commence with reading.
if remaining.is_empty() {
return io.read(buf)
}
}
// Poll the `Negotiated`, driving protocol negotiation to completion,
// including flushing of any remaining data.
let result = self.poll();
// There is still remaining data to be sent before data relating
// to the negotiated protocol can be read.
if let Ok(Async::NotReady) = result {
return Err(io::ErrorKind::WouldBlock.into())
}
if let Err(err) = result {
return Err(err.into())
}
}
}
}
impl<TInner> AsyncRead for Negotiated<TInner>
where
TInner: AsyncRead + AsyncWrite
{
unsafe fn prepare_uninitialized_buffer(&self, buf: &mut [u8]) -> bool {
match &self.state {
State::Completed { io, .. } =>
io.prepare_uninitialized_buffer(buf),
State::Expecting { io, .. } =>
io.inner_ref().prepare_uninitialized_buffer(buf),
State::Invalid => panic!("Negotiated: Invalid state")
}
}
}
impl<TInner> io::Write for Negotiated<TInner>
where
TInner: AsyncWrite
{
fn write(&mut self, buf: &[u8]) -> io::Result<usize> {
match &mut self.state {
State::Completed { io, ref mut remaining } => {
while !remaining.is_empty() {
let n = io.write(&remaining)?;
if n == 0 {
return Err(io::ErrorKind::WriteZero.into())
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
}
remaining.advance(n);
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
}
io.write(buf)
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
},
State::Expecting { io, .. } => io.write(buf),
State::Invalid => panic!("Negotiated: Invalid state")
}
}
fn flush(&mut self) -> io::Result<()> {
match &mut self.state {
State::Completed { io, ref mut remaining } => {
while !remaining.is_empty() {
let n = io.write(remaining)?;
if n == 0 {
return Err(io::Error::new(
io::ErrorKind::WriteZero,
"Failed to write remaining buffer."))
}
remaining.advance(n);
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
}
io.flush()
},
State::Expecting { io, .. } => io.flush(),
State::Invalid => panic!("Negotiated: Invalid state")
}
}
}
impl<TInner> AsyncWrite for Negotiated<TInner>
where
TInner: AsyncWrite + AsyncRead
{
fn shutdown(&mut self) -> Poll<(), io::Error> {
// Ensure all data has been flushed and expected negotiation messages
// have been received.
try_ready!(self.poll().map_err(Into::<io::Error>::into));
// Continue with the shutdown of the underlying I/O stream.
match &mut self.state {
State::Completed { io, .. } => io.shutdown(),
State::Expecting { io, .. } => io.shutdown(),
State::Invalid => panic!("Negotiated: Invalid state")
}
}
}
/// Error that can happen when negotiating a protocol with the remote.
#[derive(Debug)]
pub enum NegotiationError {
/// A protocol error occurred during the negotiation.
ProtocolError(ProtocolError),
/// Protocol negotiation failed because no protocol could be agreed upon.
Failed,
}
impl From<ProtocolError> for NegotiationError {
fn from(err: ProtocolError) -> NegotiationError {
NegotiationError::ProtocolError(err)
}
}
impl From<io::Error> for NegotiationError {
fn from(err: io::Error) -> NegotiationError {
ProtocolError::from(err).into()
}
}
impl Into<io::Error> for NegotiationError {
fn into(self) -> io::Error {
if let NegotiationError::ProtocolError(e) = self {
return e.into()
}
io::Error::new(io::ErrorKind::Other, self)
}
}
impl Error for NegotiationError {
fn source(&self) -> Option<&(dyn Error + 'static)> {
match self {
NegotiationError::ProtocolError(err) => Some(err),
_ => None,
}
}
}
impl fmt::Display for NegotiationError {
fn fmt(&self, fmt: &mut fmt::Formatter<'_>) -> Result<(), fmt::Error> {
match self {
NegotiationError::ProtocolError(p) =>
fmt.write_fmt(format_args!("Protocol error: {}", p)),
NegotiationError::Failed =>
fmt.write_str("Protocol negotiation failed.")
}
[multistream-select] Reduce roundtrips in protocol negotiation. (#1212) * Remove tokio-codec dependency from multistream-select. In preparation for the eventual switch from tokio to std futures. Includes some initial refactoring in preparation for further work in the context of https://github.com/libp2p/rust-libp2p/issues/659. * Reduce default buffer sizes. * Allow more than one frame to be buffered for sending. * Doc tweaks. * Remove superfluous (duplicated) Message types. * Reduce roundtrips in multistream-select negotiation. 1. Enable 0-RTT: If the dialer only supports a single protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application request) together with the multistream-select header and protocol proposal. Similarly, if the listener supports a proposed protocol, it can send protocol data (e.g. the actual application response) together with the multistream-select header and protocol confirmation. 2. In general, the dialer "settles on" an expected protocol as soon as it runs out of alternatives. Furthermore, both dialer and listener do not immediately flush the final protocol confirmation, allowing it to be sent together with application protocol data. Attempts to read from the negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending data. 3. A clean / graceful shutdown of an I/O stream always completes protocol negotiation. The publich API of multistream-select changed slightly, requiring both AsyncRead and AsyncWrite bounds for async reading and writing due to the implicit buffering and "lazy" negotiation. The error types have also been changed, but they were not previously fully exported. Includes some general refactoring with simplifications and some more tests, e.g. there was an edge case relating to a possible ambiguity when parsing multistream-select protocol messages. * Further missing commentary. * Remove unused test dependency. * Adjust commentary. * Cleanup NegotiatedComplete::poll() * Fix deflate protocol tests. * Stabilise network_simult test. The test implicitly relied on "slow" connection establishment in order to have a sufficient probability of passing. With the removal of roundtrips in multistream-select, it is now more likely that within the up to 50ms duration between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing, the connection is already established, causing the expectation of step == 1 to fail when receiving a Connected event, since the step may then still be 0. This commit aims to avoid these spurious errors by detecting runs during which a connection is established "too quickly", repeating the test run. It still seems theoretically possible that, if connections are always established "too quickly", the test runs forever. However, given that the delta between swarm1 and swarm2 dialing is 0-50ms and that the TCP transport is used, that seems probabilistically unlikely. Nevertheless, the purpose of the artificial dialing delay between swarm1 and swarm2 should be re-evaluated and possibly at least the maximum delay further reduced. * Complete negotiation between upgrades in libp2p-core. While multistream-select, as a standalone library and providing an API at the granularity of a single negotiation, supports lazy negotiation (and in particular 0-RTT negotiation), in the context of libp2p-core where any number of negotiations are composed generically within the concept of composable "upgrades", it is necessary to wait for protocol negotiation between upgrades to complete. * Clarify docs. Simplify listener upgrades. Since reading from a Negotiated I/O stream implicitly flushes any pending negotiation data, there is no pitfall involved in not waiting for completion.
2019-08-12 12:09:53 +02:00
}
}
#[cfg(test)]
mod tests {
use super::*;
use quickcheck::*;
use std::io::Write;
/// An I/O resource with a fixed write capacity (total and per write op).
struct Capped { buf: Vec<u8>, step: usize }
impl io::Write for Capped {
fn write(&mut self, buf: &[u8]) -> io::Result<usize> {
if self.buf.len() + buf.len() > self.buf.capacity() {
return Err(io::ErrorKind::WriteZero.into())
}
self.buf.write(&buf[.. usize::min(self.step, buf.len())])
}
fn flush(&mut self) -> io::Result<()> {
Ok(())
}
}
impl AsyncWrite for Capped {
fn shutdown(&mut self) -> Poll<(), io::Error> {
Ok(().into())
}
}
#[test]
fn write_remaining() {
fn prop(rem: Vec<u8>, new: Vec<u8>, free: u8, step: u8) -> TestResult {
let cap = rem.len() + free as usize;
let step = u8::min(free, step) as usize + 1;
let buf = Capped { buf: Vec::with_capacity(cap), step };
let rem = BytesMut::from(&rem[..]);
let mut io = Negotiated::completed(buf, rem.clone());
let mut written = 0;
loop {
// Write until `new` has been fully written or the capped buffer runs
// over capacity and yields WriteZero.
match io.write(&new[written..]) {
Ok(n) =>
if let State::Completed { remaining, .. } = &io.state {
assert!(remaining.is_empty());
written += n;
if written == new.len() {
return TestResult::passed()
}
} else {
return TestResult::failed()
}
Err(e) if e.kind() == io::ErrorKind::WriteZero => {
if let State::Completed { .. } = &io.state {
assert!(rem.len() + new.len() > cap);
return TestResult::passed()
} else {
return TestResult::failed()
}
}
Err(e) => panic!("Unexpected error: {:?}", e)
}
}
}
quickcheck(prop as fn(_,_,_,_) -> _)
}
}