427 topology bug (#433)

* fix path

* topology bug 427 test

* test with join, it works

* improve topology test, still works. add compiler test

* broken compiler test

* CompilerSpec works fine without `wrapWithXor`

* add xor to topology test, it becomes broken

* XOR topology fixed

* ForceExecModel

* Debugging topology WIP

* Fixed

Co-authored-by: DieMyst <dmitry.shakhtarin@fluence.ai>

aqua-src/so.aqua

@@ -1,6 +1,22 @@
-service TestS("some-id"):
-    t: string -> string
+service Kademlia("kad"):
+  neighborhood: -> []string
+
+service Peer("peer"):
+  timestamp_sec: -> u64
+
+service Op2("op"):
+  identity: u64 -> u64
+
+func getTwoResults(node: string) -> []u64:
+  on node:
+    nodes <- Kademlia.neighborhood()
+    res: *u64
+    for n <- nodes par:
+      on n:
+        try:
+          res <- Peer.timestamp_sec()
+    Op2.identity(res!)
+    Op2.identity(res!1)
+    Op2.identity(res!2)
+  <- res
 
-func doStuff(c: bool):
-    if c:
-        TestS.t("fr")

cli/.jvm/src/main/scala/aqua/PlatformOpts.scala

@@ -1,14 +1,12 @@
 package aqua
 
 import cats.effect.ExitCode
-import cats.effect.kernel.Async
 import com.monovore.decline.Opts
-import fs2.io.file.{Files, Path}
-import cats.syntax.applicative._
+import fs2.io.file.Path
 
 // Scala-specific options and subcommands
 object PlatformOpts {
   def opts[F[_]]: Opts[F[ExitCode]] = Opts.never
-  def getGlobalNodeModulePath: Option[Path] = None
-  def getPackagePath[F[_]: Files: Async](path: String): F[Path] = Path(path).pure[F]
+  def getGlobalNodeModulePath: List[Path] = Nil
+  def getPackagePath: Option[Path] = None
 }

cli/.jvm/src/main/scala/aqua/Test.scala

@@ -22,7 +22,7 @@ object Test extends IOApp.Simple {
       start <- IO(System.currentTimeMillis())
       _ <- AquaPathCompiler
         .compileFilesTo[IO](
-          Path("./aqua-src/hack.aqua"),
+          Path("./aqua-src/so.aqua"),
           List(Path("./aqua")),
           Option(Path("./target")),
           TypeScriptBackend,

compiler/src/test/scala/aqua/compiler/AquaCompilerSpec.scala

@@ -1,21 +1,31 @@
 package aqua.compiler
 
-import aqua.model.{CallModel, LiteralModel, VarModel}
+import aqua.model.{CallModel, IntoIndexModel, LiteralModel, ValueModel, VarModel}
 import aqua.model.transform.TransformConfig
 import aqua.model.transform.Transform
 import aqua.parser.ParserError
 import aqua.parser.Ast
 import aqua.parser.Parser
 import aqua.parser.lift.Span
-import aqua.raw.value.{LiteralRaw, ValueRaw}
-import aqua.res.{ApRes, CallRes, CallServiceRes, RestrictionRes, SeqRes}
-import aqua.types.{ArrayType, LiteralType, ScalarType, StreamType}
+import aqua.raw.value.{LiteralRaw, ValueRaw, VarRaw}
+import aqua.res.{
+  ApRes,
+  CallRes,
+  CallServiceRes,
+  FoldRes,
+  MakeRes,
+  NextRes,
+  ParRes,
+  RestrictionRes,
+  SeqRes
+}
+import aqua.types.{ArrayType, LiteralType, ScalarType, StreamType, Type}
 import org.scalatest.flatspec.AnyFlatSpec
 import org.scalatest.matchers.should.Matchers
 import cats.Id
 import cats.data.{Chain, NonEmptyChain, Validated, ValidatedNec}
 import cats.instances.string.*
-import cats.syntax.show._
+import cats.syntax.show.*
 
 class AquaCompilerSpec extends AnyFlatSpec with Matchers {
 
@@ -76,6 +86,118 @@ class AquaCompilerSpec extends AnyFlatSpec with Matchers {
 
   }
 
+  def through(peer: ValueModel, log: String = null) =
+    MakeRes.noop(peer, log)
+
+  val relay = VarRaw("-relay-", ScalarType.string)
+
+  def getDataSrv(name: String, t: Type) = {
+    CallServiceRes(
+      LiteralModel.fromRaw(LiteralRaw.quote("getDataSrv")),
+      name,
+      CallRes(Nil, Some(CallModel.Export(name, t))),
+      LiteralModel.fromRaw(ValueRaw.InitPeerId)
+    ).leaf
+  }
+
+  "aqua compiler" should "create right topology" in {
+
+    val res = compileToContext(
+      Map(
+        "index.aqua" ->
+          """service Op("op"):
+            |  identity(s: string) -> string
+            |
+            |func exec(peers: []string) -> []string:
+            |    results: *string
+            |    for peer <- peers par:
+            |        on peer:
+            |            results <- Op.identity("hahahahah")
+            |
+            |    join results[2]
+            |    <- results""".stripMargin
+      ),
+      Map.empty
+    )
+
+    res.isValid should be(true)
+    val Validated.Valid(ctxs) = res
+
+    ctxs.length should be(1)
+    val ctx = ctxs.headOption.get
+
+    val aquaRes =
+      Transform.contextRes(ctx, TransformConfig(wrapWithXor = false))
+
+    val Some(exec) = aquaRes.funcs.find(_.funcName == "exec")
+
+    val peers = VarModel("peers", ArrayType(ScalarType.string))
+    val peer = VarModel("peer", ScalarType.string)
+    val results = VarModel("results", StreamType(ScalarType.string))
+    val initPeer = LiteralModel.fromRaw(ValueRaw.InitPeerId)
+
+    val expected =
+      SeqRes.wrap(
+        getDataSrv("-relay-", ScalarType.string),
+        getDataSrv(peers.name, peers.`type`),
+        RestrictionRes("results", true).wrap(
+          SeqRes.wrap(
+            ParRes.wrap(
+              FoldRes("peer", peers).wrap(
+                ParRes.wrap(
+                  // better if first relay will be outside `for`
+                  SeqRes.wrap(
+                    through(ValueModel.fromRaw(relay)),
+                    CallServiceRes(
+                      LiteralModel.fromRaw(LiteralRaw.quote("op")),
+                      "identity",
+                      CallRes(
+                        LiteralModel.fromRaw(LiteralRaw.quote("hahahahah")) :: Nil,
+                        Some(CallModel.Export(results.name, results.`type`))
+                      ),
+                      peer
+                    ).leaf,
+                    through(ValueModel.fromRaw(relay)),
+                    through(initPeer)
+                  ),
+                  NextRes("peer").leaf
+                )
+              )
+            ),
+            CallServiceRes(
+              LiteralModel.fromRaw(LiteralRaw.quote("op")),
+              "noop",
+              CallRes(
+                results.copy(lambda = Chain.one(IntoIndexModel("2", ScalarType.string))) :: Nil,
+                None
+              ),
+              initPeer
+            ).leaf,
+            CallServiceRes(
+              LiteralModel.fromRaw(LiteralRaw.quote("op")),
+              "identity",
+              CallRes(
+                results :: Nil,
+                Some(CallModel.Export("results-fix", ArrayType(ScalarType.string)))
+              ),
+              initPeer
+            ).leaf
+          )
+        ),
+        CallServiceRes(
+          LiteralModel.fromRaw(LiteralRaw.quote("callbackSrv")),
+          "response",
+          CallRes(
+            VarModel("results-fix", ArrayType(ScalarType.string)) :: Nil,
+            None
+          ),
+          initPeer
+        ).leaf
+      )
+
+    exec.body.equalsOrShowDiff(expected) shouldBe (true)
+  }
+
   "aqua compiler" should "compile with imports" in {
 
     val res = compileToContext(

model/src/main/scala/aqua/model/OpModel.scala

@@ -40,6 +40,8 @@ object OpModel extends TreeNodeCompanion[OpModel] {
 
 sealed trait NoExecModel extends OpModel
 
+sealed trait ForceExecModel extends OpModel
+
 sealed trait GroupOpModel extends OpModel
 
 sealed trait SeqGroupModel extends GroupOpModel
@@ -86,12 +88,16 @@ case class RestrictionModel(name: String, isStream: Boolean) extends SeqGroupMod
 case class MatchMismatchModel(left: ValueModel, right: ValueModel, shouldMatch: Boolean)
     extends SeqGroupModel {
 
+  override def toString: String = s"if $left ${if (shouldMatch) "==" else "!="} $right"
+
   override def usesVarNames: Set[String] =
     left.usesVarNames ++ right.usesVarNames
 }
 
 case class ForModel(item: String, iterable: ValueModel) extends SeqGroupModel {
 
+  override def toString: String = s"for $item <- $iterable"
+
   override def restrictsVarNames: Set[String] = Set(item)
 
   override def usesVarNames: Set[String] = iterable.usesVarNames
@@ -99,6 +105,7 @@ case class ForModel(item: String, iterable: ValueModel) extends SeqGroupModel {
 }
 
 case class DeclareStreamModel(value: ValueModel) extends NoExecModel {
+  override def toString: String = s"declare $value"
 
   override def usesVarNames: Set[String] = value.usesVarNames
 }
@@ -117,21 +124,26 @@ case class PushToStreamModel(value: ValueModel, exportTo: CallModel.Export) exte
 }
 
 case class CallServiceModel(serviceId: ValueModel, funcName: String, call: CallModel)
-    extends OpModel {
+    extends ForceExecModel {
+
+  override def toString: String = s"(call _ ($serviceId $funcName) $call)"
 
   override lazy val usesVarNames: Set[String] = serviceId.usesVarNames ++ call.usesVarNames
 
   override def exportsVarNames: Set[String] = call.exportTo.map(_.name).toSet
 }
 
-case class CanonicalizeModel(operand: ValueModel, exportTo: CallModel.Export) extends OpModel {
+case class CanonicalizeModel(operand: ValueModel, exportTo: CallModel.Export)
+    extends ForceExecModel {
 
   override def exportsVarNames: Set[String] = Set(exportTo.name)
 
   override def usesVarNames: Set[String] = operand.usesVarNames
 }
 
-case class JoinModel(operands: NonEmptyList[ValueModel]) extends OpModel {
+case class JoinModel(operands: NonEmptyList[ValueModel]) extends ForceExecModel {
+
+  override def toString: String = s"join ${operands.toList.mkString(", ")}"
 
   override lazy val usesVarNames: Set[String] =
     operands.toList.flatMap(_.usesVarNames).toSet

model/src/main/scala/aqua/model/ValueModel.scala

@@ -65,13 +65,21 @@ object LambdaModel {
 }
 
 case class IntoFieldModel(field: String, `type`: Type) extends LambdaModel {
+  override def toString: String = s".$field:${`type`}"
+
   override def toRaw: LambdaRaw = IntoFieldRaw(field, `type`)
 }
 
 case class IntoIndexModel(idx: String, `type`: Type) extends LambdaModel {
   override lazy val usesVarNames: Set[String] = Set(idx).filterNot(_.forall(Character.isDigit))
 
-  override def toRaw: LambdaRaw = IntoIndexRaw(if (idx.forall(Character.isDigit)) LiteralRaw(idx, LiteralType.number) else VarRaw(idx, LiteralType.number), `type`)
+  override def toString: String = s"[$idx -> ${`type`}]"
+
+  override def toRaw: LambdaRaw = IntoIndexRaw(
+    if (idx.forall(Character.isDigit)) LiteralRaw(idx, LiteralType.number)
+    else VarRaw(idx, LiteralType.number),
+    `type`
+  )
 }
 
 case class VarModel(name: String, baseType: Type, lambda: Chain[LambdaModel] = Chain.empty)

model/transform/src/main/scala/aqua/model/transform/topology/Topology.scala

@@ -44,8 +44,7 @@ case class Topology private (
 
   lazy val firstExecutesOn: Eval[Option[List[OnModel]]] =
     (cursor.op match {
-      case _: CallServiceModel => pathOn.map(Some(_))
-      case _: JoinModel => pathOn.map(Some(_))
+      case _: ForceExecModel => pathOn.map(Some(_))
       case _ =>
         children
           .map(_.firstExecutesOn)
@@ -60,8 +59,7 @@ case class Topology private (
 
   lazy val lastExecutesOn: Eval[Option[List[OnModel]]] =
     (cursor.op match {
-      case _: CallServiceModel => pathOn.map(Some(_))
-      case _: JoinModel => pathOn.map(Some(_))
+      case _: ForceExecModel => pathOn.map(Some(_))
       case _ =>
         children
           .map(_.lastExecutesOn)
@@ -185,13 +183,22 @@ object Topology extends Logging {
     def endsOn(current: Topology): Eval[List[OnModel]] =
       current.beginsOn
 
-    protected def lastChildFinally(current: Topology): Eval[List[OnModel]] =
-      current.lastChild.map(lc =>
+    private def childFinally(
+      current: Topology,
+      child: Topology => Option[Topology]
+    ): Eval[List[OnModel]] =
+      child(current).map(lc =>
         lc.forceExit.flatMap {
           case true => current.afterOn
           case false => lc.endsOn
         }
       ) getOrElse current.beginsOn
+
+    protected def lastChildFinally(current: Topology): Eval[List[OnModel]] =
+      childFinally(current, _.lastChild)
+
+    protected def firstChildFinally(current: Topology): Eval[List[OnModel]] =
+      childFinally(current, _.firstChild)
   }
 
   trait After {
@@ -286,7 +293,8 @@ object Topology extends Logging {
         .map(t => t -> t.parent.map(_.cursor.op))
         .takeWhile {
           case (t, Some(_: ParGroupModel)) => true
-          case (t, _) => t.nextSibling.isEmpty
+          case (t, Some(_: SeqGroupModel)) => t.nextSibling.isEmpty
+          case _ => false
         }
         .map(_._1)
         .map(t => t -> t.cursor.op)
@@ -300,7 +308,11 @@ object Topology extends Logging {
         .fold(Eval.later(current.cursor.moveUp.exists(_.hasExecLater)))(_.forceExit)
 
     override def afterOn(current: Topology): Eval[List[OnModel]] =
+      current.forceExit.flatMap {
+        case true =>
           closestParExit(current).fold(afterParent(current))(_.afterOn)
+        case false => super.afterOn(current)
+      }
 
     // Parent of this branch's parent xor – fixes the case when this xor is in par
     override def pathAfter(current: Topology): Eval[Chain[ValueModel]] =
@@ -328,7 +340,7 @@ object Topology extends Logging {
 
     // Xor tag ends where any child ends; can't get first one as it may lead to recursion
     override def endsOn(current: Topology): Eval[List[OnModel]] =
-      lastChildFinally(current)
+      firstChildFinally(current)
 
   }
 
@@ -496,7 +508,7 @@ object Topology extends Logging {
 
         logger.trace("Resolved: " + resolved)
 
-        if (debug) {
+        if (debug /*|| currI == 11 || currI == 12 || currI == 14*/ ) {
           println(Console.BLUE + rc + Console.RESET)
           println(currI + " : " + rc.topology)
           println("Before: " + rc.topology.beforeOn.value)
@@ -510,7 +522,10 @@ object Topology extends Logging {
 
           println("End  : " + rc.topology.endsOn.value)
           println("After: " + rc.topology.afterOn.value)
-          println("Exit : " + rc.topology.forceExit.value)
+          println(
+            "Exit : " + (if (rc.topology.forceExit.value) Console.MAGENTA + "true" + Console.RESET
+                         else "false")
+          )
           println(
             (if (rc.topology.pathAfter.value.nonEmpty) Console.YELLOW
              else "") + "PathAfter: " + Console.RESET + rc.topology.pathAfter.value

model/transform/src/test/scala/aqua/model/transform/ModelBuilder.scala

@@ -39,6 +39,7 @@ object ModelBuilder {
   val otherRelay = LiteralRaw("other-relay", ScalarType.string)
   val otherPeer2 = LiteralRaw("other-peer-2", ScalarType.string)
   val otherRelay2 = LiteralRaw("other-relay-2", ScalarType.string)
+  val iRelay = VarRaw("i", ScalarType.string)
   val varNode = VarRaw("node-id", ScalarType.string)
   val viaList = VarRaw("other-relay-2", ArrayType(ScalarType.string))
   val valueArray = VarRaw("array", ArrayType(ScalarType.string))

model/transform/src/test/scala/aqua/model/transform/topology/TopologySpec.scala

@@ -420,6 +420,153 @@ class TopologySpec extends AnyFlatSpec with Matchers {
     proc.equalsOrShowDiff(expected) should be(true)
   }
 
+  // https://github.com/fluencelabs/aqua/issues/427
+  "topology resolver" should "create returning hops after for-par with inner `on` and xor" in {
+
+    val streamRaw = VarRaw("stream", StreamType(ScalarType.string))
+    val streamRawEl = VarRaw(
+      "stream",
+      StreamType(ScalarType.string),
+      Chain.one(IntoIndexRaw(LiteralRaw("2", ScalarType.u32), ScalarType.string))
+    )
+    val stream = ValueModel.fromRaw(streamRaw)
+    val streamEl = ValueModel.fromRaw(streamRawEl)
+
+    val init =
+      SeqModel.wrap(
+        DeclareStreamModel(stream).leaf,
+        OnModel(initPeer, Chain.one(relay)).wrap(
+          foldPar(
+            "i",
+            valueArray,
+            OnModel(iRelay, Chain.empty).wrap(
+              XorModel.wrap(
+                callModel(2, CallModel.Export(streamRaw.name, streamRaw.`type`) :: Nil),
+                OnModel(initPeer, Chain.one(relay)).wrap(
+                  callModel(4, Nil, Nil)
+                )
+              )
+            )
+          ),
+          JoinModel(NonEmptyList.one(streamEl)).leaf,
+          callModel(3, Nil, streamRaw :: Nil)
+        )
+      )
+
+    val proc = Topology.resolve(init).value
+
+    val expected =
+      SeqRes.wrap(
+        through(relay),
+        ParRes.wrap(
+          FoldRes("i", valueArray).wrap(
+            ParRes.wrap(
+              // better if first relay will be outside `for`
+              SeqRes.wrap(
+                through(relay),
+                XorRes.wrap(
+                  callRes(2, iRelay, Some(CallModel.Export(streamRaw.name, streamRaw.`type`))),
+                  SeqRes.wrap(
+                    through(relay),
+                    callRes(4, initPeer)
+                  )
+                ),
+                through(relay),
+                through(initPeer)
+              ),
+              NextRes("i").leaf
+            )
+          )
+        ),
+        CallServiceRes(
+          LiteralModel(s"\"op\"", LiteralType.string),
+          s"noop",
+          CallRes(streamEl :: Nil, None),
+          initPeer
+        ).leaf,
+        callRes(3, initPeer, None, stream :: Nil)
+      )
+    proc.equalsOrShowDiff(expected) should be(true)
+  }
+
+  // https://github.com/fluencelabs/aqua/issues/427
+  "topology resolver" should "create returning hops after for-par with inner `on` and xor, version 2" in {
+
+    val streamRaw = VarRaw("stream", StreamType(ScalarType.string))
+    val streamRawEl = VarRaw(
+      "stream",
+      StreamType(ScalarType.string),
+      Chain.one(IntoIndexRaw(LiteralRaw("2", ScalarType.u32), ScalarType.string))
+    )
+    val stream = ValueModel.fromRaw(streamRaw)
+    val streamEl = ValueModel.fromRaw(streamRawEl)
+
+    val init =
+      SeqModel.wrap(
+        DeclareStreamModel(stream).leaf,
+        OnModel(initPeer, Chain.one(relay)).wrap(
+          foldPar(
+            "i",
+            valueArray,
+            OnModel(iRelay, Chain.empty).wrap(
+              XorModel.wrap(
+                XorModel.wrap(
+                  callModel(2, CallModel.Export(streamRaw.name, streamRaw.`type`) :: Nil)
+                ),
+                OnModel(initPeer, Chain.one(relay)).wrap(
+                  callModel(4, Nil, Nil)
+                )
+              )
+            )
+          ),
+          JoinModel(NonEmptyList.one(streamEl)).leaf,
+          callModel(3, Nil, streamRaw :: Nil)
+        )
+      )
+
+    val proc = Topology.resolve(init).value
+
+    val expected =
+      SeqRes.wrap(
+        through(relay),
+        ParRes.wrap(
+          FoldRes("i", valueArray).wrap(
+            ParRes.wrap(
+              // better if first relay will be outside `for`
+              SeqRes.wrap(
+                through(relay),
+                XorRes.wrap(
+                  XorRes.wrap(
+                    callRes(2, iRelay, Some(CallModel.Export(streamRaw.name, streamRaw.`type`)))
+                  ),
+                  SeqRes.wrap(
+                    through(relay),
+                    callRes(4, initPeer)
+                  )
+                ),
+                through(relay),
+                through(initPeer)
+              ),
+              NextRes("i").leaf
+            )
+          )
+        ),
+        CallServiceRes(
+          LiteralModel(s"\"op\"", LiteralType.string),
+          s"noop",
+          CallRes(streamEl :: Nil, None),
+          initPeer
+        ).leaf,
+        callRes(3, initPeer, None, stream :: Nil)
+      )
+
+    // println(Console.MAGENTA + init.show + Console.RESET)
+    // println(Console.YELLOW + proc.show + Console.RESET)
+    // println(Console.BLUE + expected.show + Console.RESET)
+
+    proc.equalsOrShowDiff(expected) should be(true)
+  }
+
   "topology resolver" should "create returning hops on nested 'on'" in {
     val init =
       OnModel(initPeer, Chain.one(relay)).wrap(